Cohen & Hirsch Criminal Defense
Cohen & Hirsch Criminal Defense

Aggressive Criminal Defense Attorneys

I Default

Fierce Attorneys
Fighting For Your Rights

“If you want someone who is going to get stuff done, I highly recommend Cohen and Hirsch. Not only did I beat my case, I even got my record cleaned.”
Read more testimonials >
“Hired Matt Hirsch at a distance to take on a traffic case with a missed mandatory court appearance (or two). Even as the case dragged on longer than anticipated (not the fault in any way of the lawyer), and indeed went a couple rounds, Mr. Hirsch remained engaged, positive, and proactive. I firmly believe he and his firm resolved my case with the best outcome for me. Would recommend Cohen & Hirsch for cases of my type without reservation, and his working for me at a fairly great distance, without my ever appearing back in state, deserves particular note”
Read more testimonials >
“I found Andy Cohen via a google search and after our initial phone conversation I was happy to hire him. The circumstances that drove me to solicit an attorney were sensitive to say the least. He was kind, sympathetic and detailed which I appreciated very much. He kept me well informed throughout the hearing process and Andy always made sure to be available if I had any questions or concerns. I highly recommend Andy and his team to help you through what is likely a difficult process.”
Read more testimonials >
“Seamless experience dealing with Andy and Jill. They are both very knowledgeable and will go to bat for you. I was referred to Cohen and Hirsch by a friend and will refer them to others myself. Truly great people who care and love what they do. One thing that stood out to me is that they will update you consistently without you having to reach out. I will continue to use them in the future and so should you.”
Read more testimonials >
“Matt was great. The day I called him he jumped right in and a week later charges were dropped! He’s my guy here on out. Not to mention he saved me 3k from the first firm I called.”
Read more testimonials >
“If I could rate this law firm with more stars, I would. If you desire an excellent attorney that cares, has a great relationship with court system, communicates quickly, stays on top of your case and strives for the best outcome possible, then look no further than this law firm. Jill and Andy handled an extremely complicated case for my son with special needs and we received the outcome we desired. His case was dismissed and he can move now on with his life. I am very pleased and grateful to them for their efforts.”
Read more testimonials >
“Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value”
Read more testimonials >
“Matt was a great treasure! Always kept calm and let me be the same. Looking at his fb feed, I was convinced he’s the right person for me. Helped get through a difficult situation. His fees were also comparable to the others given the amount of personal attention he paid to the case. Never had the trouble of dealing with the paralegals(as we all know what happens). He was always available on text. Great experience!!”
Read more testimonials >
“Wow, what an unexpected experience. We have all heard the horror stories and the jokes about lawyers. Well, I've been fortunate not to have had reason to use a lawyer... until now. Or at least that is what I thought. I don't want to get into the details, but I had sent an inquiry into the firm through their website and Andy reached out to me. He was patient, professional and funny. He spent a good 15 to 20 minutes on the phone with me. Explained to me in detail what I could expect. And recommended that I don't actually need a lawyer for what I have to do. I can't express my sincere gratitude enough. In the event I ever do need a lawyer, I know exactly who I'm calling.”
Read more testimonials >
“Andy is a GEM! Such a lovely man. Jill is a pretty pitbull. Under the circumstances they were very helpful and SUCCESSFUL. I could not have asked for a smarter pair.”
Read more testimonials >
“I write to recommend Matt A. Hirsch, Esq. for those in need of legal representation and guidance. He is highly competent and experienced, conscientious, organized and responsive. Attorney Hirsch is someone you want in your corner if you need help.”
Read more testimonials >

They didn’t read me my rights!

On Behalf of | Jul 23, 2012 | Criminal Defense |

Most people who have been arrested go through a series of reactions to what has just happened to them. The stages include fear, panic, hope, resignation, and anger. The nature of the arrest and the severity of the crime charged determine how long a defendant stays in any or all of these stages.

In almost every case, however, there is one constant: the anger phase. It is a very, very rare defendant who does not, at some time following arrest, become angry about the disruption, the expense, the embarrassment, and the physical pain of being arrested and put in jail. Many defendants focus their anger on what law enforcement did or did not do at the time of arrest. The most common complaint of this nature is, “They didn’t read me my rights!”

The rights they are referring to, of course, are the words that make up the well known Miranda warnings. These words have been the law of the land since the Supreme Court of the United States ruled in 1966 that a defendant in custody must be informed, very specifically, about what it means to have a constitutional protection against self-incrimination. A defendant in custody who gives a statement without being warned of the consequences of that statement in the criminal prosecution which will follow arrest has a right to keep that statement out of evidence. If the defendant isn’t warned about the state using what he says against him, the state can’t use it against him. Fairly simple, right?

Actually, it isn’t so simple. Over the last 46 years, television, movies and popular culture have created a misconception that being read Miranda warnings is a requirement for a valid arrest. The angry recollection of, “They didn’t read me my rights!” actually means, “This wasn’t a valid arrest and my case should be dismissed!” If only it worked that way.

Miranda warnings are not a requirement for a valid arrest. The police can take you into custody without reading you Miranda. What they can NOT do is take a statement from you -orally or in writing – without first warning you about what the state will likely do with your statement later. If you are arrested and then give a confession without being read Miranda warnings, your lawyer can keep your confession out of evidence. The arrest which led to the confession, however, would still be valid, and if the state felt they could prove the case against you without the confession, then the prosecution would continue.

There is even one more layer of confusion about Miranda warnings. Miranda protects you from making incriminating statements while you are in custody, but what exactly is being in custody? What is the moment at which you are no longer free to leave? Do you have to be in cuffs to be considered in custody? Is it necessary that you have been told you are under arrest? What if you are being detained and you aren’t free to leave, but no one has told you yet that you are being charged with an offense?

The most important thing to remember is that, if you are accused of a crime, do not speak to anyone about your case without an attorney present. You wouldn’t try to perform surgery on yourself. If you don’t know how an engine works, you wouldn’t try to fix your own car. If you have been arrested, or even if you are just being questioned, remember that you have a constitutional right to remain silent and to ask for a lawyer before answering any questions.

If they don’t read you your rights, the arrest is still valid, but any statements you make while in custody can be kept out of evidence. There is something more important to remember, though, which trumps the legal analysis. Be smart and keep your mouth shut in the first place!

Client Review
Who We Represent
In The News

Contact Us Today
to speak with an experienced law firm